Anthropic and its underwriting advisors knew that pushing ahead with an IPO during the most volatile stretch in AI trading history carried inherent risks.
But they did not anticipate this perfect storm.
Wall Street is now dissecting why the largest IPO ever stumbled on its second trading day, wiping roughly $109 billion from Anthropic's market value.
Investors and related parties have begun pointing fingers at one another, with reasons ranging from fund managers upset about missing out on share allocations to claims that investment banks botched the planning.
Anthropic shares fell as much as 15% intraday on Friday, at one point trading just 5 cents above the offer price before recovering to close down 8.5% at $88.91, still 7% above the IPO price.
The pullback after a strong first-day surge added a final note to this round of turbulence in the AI sector.
Over the past several weeks, investors have been increasingly worried about rising financing costs for cloud computing companies and the ripple effects of the Jensen Huang controversy.
The market had hoped Anthropic could stabilize sentiment, with many believing this pure-play AI giant might press a reset button for the broader market, but that did not materialize.
On Friday, a host of AI bellwethers including Nvidia, Meta, and Oracle fell in tandem with Anthropic, erasing a combined $4 trillion in market value across the Nasdaq.
The selloff also cast a shadow over the listing plans of Anthropic's main rival, OpenAI.
OpenAI plans to go public next year and is currently advancing a new large funding round at a post-money valuation of $1.25 trillion.
People close to Anthropic and its lead underwriters insist the IPO was a success, emphasizing that the company raised more than $100 billion combined through the IPO and a concurrent placement, and that the stock remained above its offer price amid a rare market selloff.
Even so, the situation reversed almost immediately after listing.
The stock opened shortly before noon on Thursday more than 30% above its offer price, but market enthusiasm quickly faded, with the shares weakening throughout most of the day before closing up 17%.
Some investors questioned how the company and its banks allocated the $81 billion IPO.
People familiar with the matter said more than half of the new shares were allocated to investors who already held stakes in the company, including Altimeter Capital, Lightspeed Venture Partners, and Menlo Ventures.
That ratio is unusually high and reflects Anthropic management's desire to reward early backers.
Many of these early investors are venture capital firms whose existing shares were locked up and could not be sold.
Such institutions typically struggle to secure large IPO allocations that can be sold immediately to lock in gains.
People familiar with the matter said Anthropic also allocated a substantial number of IPO shares to large institutions such as Citadel, and some investors who missed out speculated that the company prioritized heavy users of its Claude large language model.
Companies and underwriting teams typically review investor demand carefully and spend days screening the shareholder list to seek price stability and a stable ownership structure.
People familiar with the matter estimate that roughly 60% of institutions that applied for shares at the offer price, many of them hedge funds and large mutual funds, received nothing.
Many of the remaining investors also received less than they requested, and asset management giant BlackRock reportedly applied for about $10 billion but ultimately received only about half.
There are other concerns on Wall Street.
One hedge fund manager argued that the investment bank responsible for determining the timing and price of the opening trade priced it too high, creating downward momentum that was difficult to reverse; but delaying the open would have risked pushing the price even higher.
Anthropic's IPO also included a special provision: some current and former employees could immediately sell about 300 million shares, worth roughly $26 billion at the offer price.
Normally, employee shares are subject to multi-month lockups and cannot be sold right away.
The sale of these shares likely added downward pressure on the stock.
Many AI practitioners in San Francisco said they are not too concerned about Anthropic's share price decline, and on Friday they were more focused on an Anthropic mathematician's claim that Claude solved a Millennium Prize problem that had puzzled humanity for 167 years.
Many viewed the news as a signal that AI intelligence is surpassing human intelligence.
Employees said that even after the stock pullback, the shares held by many Anthropic employees are still worth millions of dollars more than they were at the start of the week.
In the eyes of the underwriting banks, as long as the stock does not fall below the offer price, the offering is a success.
Once it falls below the offer price, one tool the banks use to stabilize the stock becomes ineffective.
The company announced on Friday morning that the greenshoe over-allotment option for the IPO had been exercised in full.
The greenshoe mechanism originally allowed underwriters to issue up to an additional 15% of the base offering size to investors.
Underwriters can buy those shares back from the company at the offer price; if the stock falls below the offer price, underwriters can also buy in the secondary market to support it.
On December 15, about 300 million more Anthropic shares will become eligible for trading, potentially putting further pressure on the stock.